Arbor Hills Monitor

Fact check: November 18 MMPC meeting

Washtenaw County Materials Management Planning Committee  ·  Arbor Hills Monitor  ·  November 19, 2026  ·  arborhillsmonitor.org

Statements by GFL, EGLE and the Arbor Hills Monitor, checked against the public record. Prepared by Trisha Kunst, Arbor Hills Monitor; item 10 checks a statement by the author. Corrections: [email protected].

Not accurate: the record contradicts the statement. Missing context: accurate as far as it goes, but leaves out something that changes the picture.

1

Counting violation notices is not the same as compliance

GFLMissing context
Slide title: "Air Quality Compliance Record" (a count of formal violation notices by year)

Paragraph 5.12 of the 2022 Consent Judgment (a court-entered settlement between EGLE and Arbor Hills Landfill, Inc.) covers "subsurface methane detection exceedances east of Napier Road," where gas has moved underground away from the waste. A November 6, 2026 letter from Assistant Attorney General Danielle Allison-Yokom, answering this fact check's author, states:

  • "Arbor Hills still has not obtained compliance with Paragraph 5.12. EGLE continues to require Arbor Hills to take additional steps to address the methane exceedances."
  • "You express concern that Arbor Hills' noncompliance is not documented because EGLE has not issued violations notices or stipulated penalties. EGLE uses the monitoring results that record methane exceedances to track and document Arbor Hills' noncompliance with the consent judgment's requirements." (emphasis added)
  • Why no penalties have been assessed: "Because Arbor Hills has been working cooperatively with EGLE to address the methane exceedances, EGLE has not assessed stipulated penalties."
  • "EGLE will not agree to terminate the requirements in Paragraph 5.12 until compliance is achieved."

EGLE approved the most recent work plan in February 2025. Gas probes are monitoring wells set in the soil outside the waste; they detect methane that has migrated underground through the soil. Their records (GFL probe reports, EGLE FOIA E700131; Consent Judgment quarterly reports) show at least one probe above the lower explosive limit (LEL: 5% methane, the lowest concentration that can ignite) in each of the 24 quarters since GFL took over in October 2020. Paragraph 5.12 is titled "Lower Explosive Limit": a reading above 100% of the LEL is an exceedance, with or without a violation notice. On June 12, 2026, probe AHMP15R2 read 1,658% of the LEL (about 83% methane).

GFL slide titled Air Quality Compliance Record, a bar chart of violation counts by yearClick to enlarge
GFL's “Air Quality Compliance Record” slide, shown at the meeting. It shows only formal violation notices. The Assistant Attorney General's letter says EGLE tracks Consent Judgment gas-migration noncompliance through monitoring results, not notices.
Arbor Hills Monitor handout: EGLE tracks noncompliance through monitoring, not violation noticesClick to enlarge
The Arbor Hills Monitor handout on the recent Assistant Attorney General letter, given to committee members at the meeting.
2

Gas probe monitoring and step-down condition

GFLMissing context
Slide text: "31 Gas Monitoring Probes / Target Probes: Monitor AHMP0014/14R, 15R/15R2, 16R, 28R2, and 0013 weekly. / Frequency Step-Down: Revert to quarterly after 1 yr with no exceedance; revert to weekly if exceeded."

The step-down condition has never been met for probe AHMP15R2. In GFL's Consent Judgment quarterly reports to EGLE from April 2022 through June 2026, it never went a year without an exceedance; its longest stretch without one was about five and a half months (March 19 to September 3, 2025).

GFL slide titled Daily Cover, Repairs and Gas MonitoringClick to enlarge
GFL's slide on gas probe monitoring, including the weekly-to-quarterly step-down.
3

Surface-emissions monitoring (SEM) and the excluded area

GFLMissing context
Slide text: "4-day Quarterly SEM: Perform Quarterly walking SEM inspections for methane at a 30m interval path, all cover penetrations, and areas of erosion or stressed vegetation."

EGLE's June 16, 2026 inspection found 75 surface locations where methane exceeded 500 ppm above background. The highest, 148,682 ppm (about 15% methane), was at a cover penetration (JB9, Penetration 502R) in the northern active area. GFL told the committee its surveys exclude steep slopes, dangerous areas and active areas, including the northeast corner. Federal rules (40 CFR 63.1958(d)) allow "steep slopes or other dangerous areas" to be excluded. Before the inspection, EGLE's June 15, 2026 records request asked that any excluded area "include a justification for the exclusion provided by the SEM technician."

GFL slide titled Surface Emission MonitoringClick to enlarge
GFL's surface-emissions monitoring slide.
4

Count of approved temperature waivers

GFLMissing context
Slide text and remarks: The slide read "9 HOVs approved by EGLE." GFL also said the site has had "two higher temperature wells" with requests for higher operating values.

EGLE's April 7, 2026 renewal letter approved higher operating values (HOVs: EGLE-approved wellhead temperature limits above the federal standard) for 16 locations (14 gas wells and 2 leachate sumps) through May 1, 2028. GFL's "9" matches the wells with an approved waiver among those that exceeded 131°F in its consultant's March-to-September 2026 review window; "two" matches the gas wells in that window that exceeded 145°F (wells 0279 at 154.6°F and 0313 at 148.5°F). Both figures describe a narrow slice of one review period, not the 16 locations EGLE has authorized.

GFL slide titled Elevated Temperature Definitions, with Arbor Hills HOV historyClick to enlarge
GFL's “Elevated Temperature Definitions” slide, right column: “9 HOVs approved by EGLE.”
5

The October 2026 engineering review of hot wells

GFLMissing context
Slide text: "An independent engineering review concludes the data provide no evidence of problematic ETLF conditions, a subsurface fire, or other subsurface reaction, with temperatures consistent with typical gas extraction."

The review is an October 15, 2026 letter from GFL's consultant, CEC. Its wellhead-temperature and methane-to-CO2 evaluation covers only March to September 2026; it also cites drilling and downhole records back to 2020, without the context of gas levels when those downhole records were taken. Table 1 lists a peak of 135.8°F for well AHW272R4 (June 26, 2026). On March 14, 2025, outside the period of this review, the same well reached 177°F, under a 180°F ceiling EGLE approved for it on February 19, 2025.

The review compared each well's six-month average methane-to-CO2 ratio ("The lowest average ratio observed among these wells was 1.21"); an average can hide a short drop. It does not mention the earlier high-temperature episodes (2021 to 2022 and late 2024 to 2025; see item 8) or a 2019 episode under the previous owner.

GFL slide on elevated temperatures citing an independent engineering reviewClick to enlarge
The same slide, citing the October 2026 engineering review.
Hottest wellhead reading in each quarter (°F)140150160170180190145°F federal standard177.5°F · May 2021 · well 312R182.5°F · July 2022 · well 16R6177.0°F · March 2025 · well 272R4202120222023202420252026
The October 2026 review’s wellhead evaluation covers only March to September 2026, the flat stretch at the far right. It does not mention the three peaks: May 2021, July 2022 and March 2025 (GFL wellfield data).
6

Southeast Michigan waste market share

GFLNot accurate
Slide text: Arbor Hills receives "nearly 25% of all waste generated in Southeast Michigan."

In fiscal year 2025, waste generated from the seven SEMCOG (Southeast Michigan Council of Governments) counties and landfilled in Michigan totaled about 9.35 million tons. Arbor Hills received about 1.76 million tons of it, or 18.9% (EGLE totals include alternative daily cover; without it the share is lower). Other reasonable definitions of the region give 17% to 21%. Figures near 25% appear only when Arbor Hills is compared with other landfills, such as its three nearest neighbors (Sauk Trail Hills, Woodland Meadows and Carleton Farms: 25.6%), not with the waste the region generates.

Percentages must be used carefully, and members are encouraged to ask questions. One example: in fiscal year 2025, 30% of Washtenaw's landfilled waste went to Arbor Hills, yet Washtenaw was only 7% of the waste accepted there (about 135,000 of Washtenaw's 450,000 tons; 135,000 of Arbor Hills' 1.88 million tons).

Contrast the slide's 25% with a statement that is true: Arbor Hills has 3% to 4% of the remaining landfill capacity in Southeast Michigan. At the end of fiscal year 2025 it had 7,219,565 cubic yards of permitted space left: about 4% of the 172,952,209 in the 11 noncaptive landfills in the seven SEMCOG counties, and about 3% of the 238,869,044 in the 16 landfills in the committee's regional capacity assessment. These count permitted space only, not GFL's proposed new landfill.

GFL slide titled History of Arbor Hills LandfillClick to enlarge
GFL's “History of Arbor Hills Landfill” slide, left column: “nearly 25% of all waste generated in Southeast Michigan.”
Remaining permitted capacity, 11 SEMCOG-county landfills (cubic yards)Carleton Farms: 69.6M (40.2%)Woodland Meadows: 42.8M (24.7%)Pine Tree Acres: 22.3M (12.9%)Smiths Creek: 16.2M (9.4%)Arbor Hills: 7.2M (4.2%)Riverview: 5.6M (3.3%)Eagle Valley: 4.8M (2.8%)4 others: 4.4M (2.5%)Total: 173.0 million cubic yards
EGLE, Report of Solid Waste Landfilled in Michigan, FY2025, Table 4 (as of Sept. 30, 2025). Permitted space only; GFL’s proposed new landfill is not counted. This is space, not waste: the capacity is open to waste generated anywhere, including outside Southeast Michigan. In FY2025, about 6% of the waste Arbor Hills accepted came from outside the seven SEMCOG counties, mostly Canada and Ohio (EGLE Appendix D). “4 others”: Sauk Trail Hills, Vienna Junction, Matlin Road and Oakland Heights.
7

Elevated wellhead temperatures and the federal rule

GFLMissing context
Said in the room (Nov. 18, 2026)What federal rules require

GFL: "There's a lot of wells out there in the number of landfills that operate in the 150s, the 160s ... as routine operating temperatures."

40 CFR 63.1958(c)(1) (effective Sept. 27, 2021): "operate each interior wellhead in the collection system with a landfill gas temperature less than 62.8 degrees Celsius (145 degrees Fahrenheit)."

40 CFR 63.1960(a)(4)(i): "action must be initiated to correct the exceedance within 5 days." If 145°F is not achieved in 15 days: root cause analysis and correction within 60 days. If not corrected in 60 days: corrective action completed within 120 days of the first reading.

40 CFR 63.1958(c)(2) (HOV approval): elevated temperature operation requires a demonstration that it "neither causes fires nor significantly inhibits anaerobic decomposition by killing methanogens."

With an EGLE-approved HOV, a well may operate above 145°F up to its approved limit; at any other well, a reading at or above 145°F starts the correction deadlines. Calling the 150s and 160s routine blurs that difference.

Above 158°F (70°C), "few methanogens survive" (Krause et al., an EPA-led study, 2023), so a well that hot would have difficulty meeting the demonstration the law requires.

Wells at or above 145°F vs wells with an HOV waiver, by half-yearAt or above 145°FGas wells with an HOV waiver (highest ceiling above)051015208n/a’21 H18n/a’21 H28n/a’22 H17n/a’22 H26n/a’23 H15n/a’23 H2513170°’24 H1313170°’24 H2614180°’25 H1615180°’25 H2314180°’26 H1
Left bar: gas wells at or above the 145°F federal standard in each half-year (GFL wellfield data; 2025 highlighted). Right bar: gas wells with an EGLE higher operating value (HOV) waiver at the end of the half-year, with the highest approved ceiling above it (EGLE letters of April 30, 2024, July 10, 2024, February 19, 2025, July 23, 2025 and April 7, 2026). The two leachate sumps with waivers are not counted. Waivers date to 2019, but the 2019 to 2023 letters are not on file, so 2021 to 2023 show n/a. The April 2026 renewal covers 14 gas wells; it does not mention well AHW263R5, whose July 23, 2025 waiver states no end date, so the 2026 count may be 15.
8

When the hot-well problem began, and whether it has changed

EGLEMissing context
Said in the room: "this issue was identified back in 2021, something like that" ... "we agree the findings of this report. And we have had our own independent experts from academia and within EPA at the facility evaluating just this issue. And it is not a concern for us at this point. We are monitoring it and have been since twenty nineteen. And there has been very little to no change." (meeting audio)

When it began: EGLE records an April 2, 2019 "Elevated Temperature Landfill (ETLF) Event visit" and an April 11, 2019 Violation Notice, both under the previous owner, consistent with monitoring since 2019.

Whether it has changed: read as a process, wellhead temperature is not in control: it does not stay within its limits, the federal standards of 131°F (40 CFR 60 Subpart WWW) and 145°F (40 CFR 63.1958(c)(1)), both of which still apply. The hottest readings reached 177.5°F in 2021 and 182.5°F in 2022, fell to the 150s°F in 2023 and 2024, rose to 177.0°F in March 2025, and have stayed in the 150s°F since mid-2025. Wells at or above 145°F went from 8 in 2021 to 3 in late 2024, 6 in both halves of 2025, and 3 in early 2026. The methane-to-carbon-dioxide ratio shows when reactions likely happened: among readings at or above 145°F, 27% to 35% were below 0.9 (the level GFL's consultant, CEC, treats as a possible sign of elevated-temperature conditions) in each half-year from 2021 through early 2022, and 22% in early 2025. None were in 2023, 2024 or since mid-2025.

Hottest wellhead reading in each quarter (°F)140150160170180190145°F federal standard177.5°F · May 2021 · well 312R182.5°F · July 2022 · well 16R6177.0°F · March 2025 · well 272R4202120222023202420252026Methane-to-CO₂ ratio at hot wells (readings at or above 145°F)012340.9: possible elevated-temperature sign (CEC)’21 H134%’21 H227%’22 H135%’22 H213%’23 H10%’23 H20%’24 H10%’24 H20%’25 H122%’25 H20%’26 H10%<0.9*
From GFL’s wellfield data. Top: the hottest reading anywhere in the wellfield each quarter, showing three high peaks, the highest in July 2022. Bottom: methane-to-CO₂ ratio for every reading at or above 145°F (3 to 8 hot wells per half-year); boxes span the middle half of readings, the bar is the median, whiskers run from the 5th to the 95th percentile. *Share of those hot readings below 0.9.
9

How Arbor Hills compares with other landfills

EGLEMissing context
Said in the room: "And so comparatively speaking, this landfill is on the same level as others. We have, you know, no bigger issues here." (meeting audio; filler words removed)

The June 16, 2026 inspection letter from EGLE's Air Quality Division states that "approximately 50% of the vertical wells showed signs of impairment which is above average compared to other landfills that SEM inspections have been conducted at." Impaired wells are not collecting gas as designed, for example because of water, heat or damage.

EGLE Air Quality Division · inspection letter · June 16, 2026
“approximately 50% of the vertical wells showed signs of impairment which is above average compared to other landfills that SEM inspections have been conducted at.”
MiEnviro nSITE 5235825008795529644
From EGLE's letter on its June 16, 2026 surface-emissions inspection.
10

Who said NMOC emissions double every 18°F

Arbor Hills Monitor (Trisha Kunst)Not accurate (source)
Said in the room: "The EPA told us in the early 2000s that for every 18 degrees temperature goes up, the NMOCs a landfill produces double." (meeting audio)

The rule of thumb is real, but the source is the federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), not EPA. ATSDR's 2001 Landfill Gas Primer, Chapter 2: "As a general rule, emissions of NMOCs double with every 18° F increase in temperature." NMOCs are nonmethane organic compounds. Those found in GFL's September 1, 2026 sample of Arbor Hills landfill gas include benzene and vinyl chloride (both known human carcinogens), toluene, xylenes and ethylbenzene.

ATSDR · Landfill Gas Primer · 2001 · Chapter 2
“As a general rule, emissions of NMOCs double with every 18° F increase in temperature.”
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry
The source of the 18°F rule of thumb: ATSDR, not EPA.
11

Whether the hot wells are constantly monitored

GFLMissing context
Said in the room: "right now we do two times a month, if not more, where we touch every well. So we're constantly looking at those parameters." EGLE repeated the description: "as Tony mentioned ... they're constantly monitoring these wells." (meeting audio)

"Constantly" here means hand readings: a technician visits each wellhead with a portable meter. GFL's reports to EGLE show fewer visits than described: from August 2025 through July 2026 (534 wells), each well was read on average 1.7 times a month; in 58% of well-months it was read once, and in 87% once or twice. (The reports may not list every field visit.) Federal rules require a reading at least monthly, and weekly for a well above 145°F unless EGLE has approved a higher operating temperature for it.

Continuous monitoring exists and has been required elsewhere: sensors on each wellhead can read the well around the clock. At California's Chiquita Canyon Landfill, the air district's March 21, 2024 abatement order required a "real-time, remote monitoring system" for "well pressure and landfill gas temperature at different well depths" on every well in the reaction area by October 22, 2024.

Times each well was read in a month (share of well-months)0%20%40%60%57.8%Once29%Twice8.5%3 times4.7%4+ times
How many times each gas well was read in a month, August 2025 to July 2026: share of 5,626 well-months (534 wells; GFL wellfield reports filed with EGLE).
12

Whether each gas well operates independently

GFLMissing context
Said in the room: "Each [well] operates independently from another one. So depending on uh the waste mass, what's what's in that particular part of the [landfill]..." (meeting audio; the transcript reads "row")

GFL's point, that each well's readings reflect the waste around it, is accurate. What it leaves out: the wells share one vacuum system, and the hot wells are clustered. A landfill gas system is "a large number of interconnected vertical gas-collection wells and horizontal pipes in trenches," so a change at one well changes what its neighbors collect (Loci Controls and EPP Services technical paper).

At Arbor Hills, EGLE's February 19, 2025 letter approving a 180°F limit for well AHW272R4 says the well "is currently situated within a 250-foot radi[us] of WOI AHW285R3," another designated hot well, and that "the predecessor well AHW272R3" was already a Well of Interest in 2022. The replacement well later ran hot too (177°F, March 2025). The Arbor Hills Monitor's thermal map of GFL's readings groups the wells that peaked at or above 131°F into two areas, an eastern hot core and a western warm field.

EGLE Air Quality Division · HOV approval letter · February 19, 2025
“The well is a vertical extraction well that is currently situated within a 250-foot radi[us] of WOI AHW285R3.”
EGLE letter to Arbor Hills Landfill approving a 180°F operating value for well AHW272R4
Two designated hot wells within 250 feet of each other, in EGLE's words.
Sources: Letter (by email) from Assistant Attorney General Danielle Allison-Yokom, Nov. 6, 2026  |  Mich. Admin. Code R 299.4433  |  40 CFR 63.1958 and 63.1960 (ecfr.gov, accessed Nov. 17, 2026)  |  GFL gas-probe reports (EGLE FOIA E700131) and Consent Judgment quarterly reports  |  EGLE AQD surface-emissions inspection letter, June 16, 2026 (MiEnviro nSITE 5235825008795529644)  |  EGLE AQD records request to GFL, June 15, 2026 (email, item 4)  |  CEC review for GFL, Oct. 15, 2026, Table 1 (filed with EGLE Nov. 12, 2026; MiEnviro nSITE -1828257951663218855)  |  EGLE AQD HOV renewal, Apr. 7, 2026  |  EGLE, Report of Solid Waste Landfilled in Michigan, FY2025, Appendix D and Table 4 (remaining capacity)  |  EGLE ETLF event visit, Apr. 2, 2019 (nSITE -1740242630860329216), and Violation Notice, Apr. 11, 2019  |  EGLE AQD HOV approval for AHW272R4, Feb. 19, 2025  |  GFL wellfield data, readings from March 2021 to mid-2026  |  Krause et al., "Understanding landfill gas behavior at elevated temperature landfills," Waste Management (2023)  |  ATSDR, Landfill Gas Primer (2001), Ch. 2  |  GFL flare-inlet gas sample (EPA TO-15), Sept. 1, 2026  |  South Coast AQMD Hearing Board Case No. 6177-4 (Chiquita Canyon), Condition No. 66, as quoted in the operator's April 19, 2024 monitoring plan  |  Meeting audio, Nov. 18, 2026 MMPC.